Guest Verified #fundie disqus.com

Guest Verified:
Science has not determined that transgenderism is a physical condition with reproduceable results.

HarmNoOne:
it is true. what is not determined is the issue of being gender nonbinary.

Guest Verified:
It is not true. You cannot produce one scientific study that proves it.

HarmNoOne:
there are many papers on it

Guest Verified:
Name one.

HarmNoOne:
ill name you several
Transgender Kids Show Consistent Gender Identity Across Measures - Association for Psychological Science
Landmark study to track ‘pioneer’ generation of transgender children - University of Washington
Landmark paper published on transgender health issues - The Lancet
‘They Aren’t Confused’: Landmark Study Shows Transgender Children Have Consistent, ‘Deeply-Held’ Gender Identity - Psychological Science
Transgender People, Gender Identity and Gender Expression - The American Psychological Association

Guest Verified:
Yeah, you mentioned these before under another handle. Those are all psychology opinion pieces. They are not scientific studies and there is no transgender gene.

HarmNoOne:
i dont have another handle.
psychological opinions are what eventually form scientific consensus and you can see that several of those are landmark papers. do you want more examples, they are easy enough to obtain, or will you just blithly shoot them all down too because you don't believe in psychology?

Guest Verified:
a.) Psychology is not a real science.
b.) The articles you provided do not prove there is a transgender gene. They do, however, prove transgenderism is a mental illness, which is the field psychology attempts to address.

HarmNoOne:
psychology is absolutely a real science, where did you learn it wasnt? and since when is the presence of a transgender gene the only proof of transgenders existing? mental illness is just a tag religious people hang on things they are too lazy to explore.

7 comments

Confused?

So were we! You can find all of this, and more, on Fundies Say the Darndest Things!

To post a comment, you'll need to Sign in or Register. Making an account also allows you to claim credit for submitting quotes, and to vote on quotes and comments. You don't even need to give us your email address.