Quote# 132843

The argument you present in itself does not and cannot define the truths and power of God. Nor can it contain an answer
to the actual events which come to pass. Need new arguments the one you bring to the table outdated.


Circular reasoning cannot raise the dead. Circular reasoning cannot heal the sick... Are you sure you are not brain washed
and hiding behind words because you don't understand the persons God, Christ and the Holy Spirit? Circular reasoning in no way
can explain who they are individually or the works men have done because of them. Circular reasoning is redundant you are wearing the altogether as far as the kings new clothes.


You see above the circular reasoning is man made and did not exist till after God, Christ and the Holy Spirit. You explain God,
Christ and the Holy Spirit without using someone elses reasoning or words. The truth is you cannot which means you are not in a
position to make judgements about things you cannot reason for yourself.


You don't have a reasoning... You cannot even explain who God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit, are. You cannot even reason for yourself
you use stupid and unintelligent words like 'circular arguments' because you are ignorant of the truth
about the subjects at hand.

Your last paragraph is just stupid. The rest of your post is you just trying to reflect your own beliefs about subjects (you know
absolutely nothings about) on to them. You use 'man-made' arguments without any real understanding of them and think somehow it proves your disbelief. Nothing really blinding there.

The end and beginning is God. The only circular argument which is a circular argument that begins and ends on a truth. The greatest proof that God exists and always will whatever you believe that existence to be, is that no one has managed to do away with the belief.
The reason for that, is no science and no man can disprove his existence. It isn't a fallacy and therefore it exists because it is
the only circular reasoning which is based on truth. A truth your writing about him acknowledges he will always exist.

Being clever is not about what you think you know. It is about what knowing what you know about whom you know. @ Sassy.
[/quote]

Sassy, Religion and Ethics 12 Comments [10/12/2017 3:11:55 AM]
Fundie Index: 8
Submitted By: Nearly Sane
Username:
Comment:



1 | bottom

SomeApe

Circular reasoning is redundant


I would say it's almost completely the opposite.

10/12/2017 3:17:39 AM

Shepard Solus

Circular reasoning cannot raise the dead. Circular reasoning cannot heal the sick... Are you sure you are not brain washed

THAT'S WHAT WE'VE BEEN SAYING TO YOU FOR YEARS, YOU DUNCE! For years your only argument has been "It's true because the Bible doesn't lie, and we know the Bible doesn't lie because god said so, and we know god said so because it's in the Bible".

You cannot even explain who God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit, are.

Mythological figures from an ancient Middle Eastern religion. Simple.

How does Sassy even function? She's like Amos' dumber twin, and it terrifies me to think that there exists any pairing in which Amos is the smart one. If I suffered a stroke while trapped in a room with only him, a goldfish and phone, I'd do my best to get the phone into the fish tank.

10/12/2017 3:24:54 AM

Happy Atheist

'The greatest proof that God exists and always will whatever you believe that existence to be, is that no one has managed to do away with the belief.'


And thus Hinduism is proved infallibly true?

10/12/2017 4:19:14 AM

Azereaux

That's a lot of words to say that you don't understand what they mean by "circular reasoning". Also, a tautology is not an argument. I'd say that as far as proofs go, it's even lazier than circular reasoning. "It is, period" is not clever, and doesn't demonstrate any sort of knowledge.

You aren't clever. You're just repeating the same thing over and over and calling it an argument. And, of course, dismissing anything other than your poor strategy as not applicable.

In short, you are an idiot. You couldn't even convince a devout Christian raised in a Christian environment that there is a God.

10/12/2017 6:06:49 AM

Lucilius

Short translation: "ME AM KNOW WORDS! ME AM SMART!"

10/12/2017 6:47:30 AM

KingOfRhye

no science and no man can disprove his existence


So, in other words, God is unfalsifiable? Got it....

10/12/2017 6:52:10 AM

Anon-e-moose

The Flying Spaghetti Monster. JR 'Bob' Dobbs. Cthulhu. Eris. Celestia & Luna. Haruhi Suzumiya. As it is written, so they exist too. [/'Teach the Controversy']

I know that they can't. So what's stopping your 'God' from regenerating the missing limbs of amputees, Sissy...?!

There. I've run circular rings - using your own logic - around you.

And now it is time for the Buddy Jesus statue on top of your television set to explode into nonexistence.

[/Monty Python]

10/12/2017 7:10:00 AM

Swede

It's not our job to explain who God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit are. That's not how burden of proof works, dearie.



No-one has managed to do away with the belief in Hinduism, Judaism, Buddhism, Islam either.

Being clever isn't something you have to worry about, dearie.

10/12/2017 9:11:48 AM

Philbert McAdamia

A good test for irony meters.

Need new arguments the one you bring to the table outdated. *Ahem*

10/12/2017 9:22:39 AM

Yossarian Lives

Well if this is what constitutes as a God given argument then it's little wonder that man made arguments have gained traction in recent history.

10/12/2017 9:30:02 AM

Kanna

I'm feeling a little dizzy just now. Or perhaps that is Sassy that I see spinning like a little glittery pinwheel in the breeze.

10/12/2017 11:27:30 AM

Thinking Allowed


10/13/2017 8:04:18 AM

1 | top: comments page