This may well be a Poe since apparently that sub is filled with troll and Poe posts but considering these manbabies' general lack of self-awareness, it may well be genuine.
All the traits this dipshit mentions do matter, unfortunately, "incels" tend to be just as shallow as they always whine women are. "Nice Guys"TM, guys who are being "nice" because they think it's going to help them get a girlfriend/laid, are often to be the larval stage of "incels". Which is why I will again tell everyone that if you know anyone who is posting whiny "friend zoned nice guy" bullshit on their socials, keep an eye on them. They may outgrow it but they may also start down the dark path to "inceldom".
Again, I've seen guys who are short, heavy-set and "ugly" do just fine with the ladies. Yes, "incels" dismiss guys like this as being "cucked beta orbiters" because their girlfriends and wives don't look like this "Stacey" strawman they've created but the fact remains is that their guys are in happy, stable relationships with people they care about and love. They're also having sex regularly putting it in terms that "incels" can understand and are obsessed with.
Which is a lot more than I can say for these whiny assholes.
Edit:>I think Cracked might be on to something, these guys act EXACTLY like a cult.
As I've pointed out a few times, the "manosphere" tries to distance itself from "incels". They're a bit like the crazy, disfigured sibling they keep locked in the attic and hope that no one notices the banging on the ceiling and deranged screaming that constantly drifts down.
When even something that begged its mother for sex considers you to be "scum" you know that individual is pretty bad. But hey, Marjie has one leg up on the "supreme gentleman"; its actually had sex. But, since it was a couple incidents of date rape from my understanding, plus allegedly forcing itself on a mentally ill woman, that makes it scum too.
Even then, calling Cammy-Poo and the "supreme gentleman" scum is an insult to scum since it contributes to the eco-system. Unlike Marjie who contributes nothing to the world and commits welfare fraud.